Performing for the Crowd: When Everyone Is Watching

There's a strange feeling that creeps in when you post something online: a mix of hope, anxiety, and calculation. You wonder how it will land—not just with your friends, but with coworkers, strangers, maybe even future employers. So you edit. You smooth the edges. You present a version of yourself that's safe, likable, shareable.

This isn't a coincidence. It's a product of how platforms are built. When we live in public, we perform.

Self-Presentation and Social Surveillance

Psychologists have long studied how people shape their behavior based on who's watching. This is known as self-presentation—the act of managing impressions. Offline, we do this naturally: you speak differently to your boss than to your best friend. You wear different clothes to dinner than to the gym.

But when the boundaries between audiences disappear, it gets harder. Social theorists call this social surveillance—the idea that we're always potentially being observed, and that this shapes our behavior in subtle, persistent ways. Even when no one is watching, the possibility that someone might be is enough to make us curate.

Context Collapse: One Audience, All the Time

On social media, this problem is amplified through context collapse—the flattening of multiple audiences into one. You're not just sharing with friends. You're sharing with coworkers, parents, exes, followers, and strangers—simultaneously.

There's no way to tailor your message to each group, so you default to what feels safest or what gets the most engagement. Over time, this leads to a kind of performance: polished, reactive, optimized for attention. It's not necessarily inauthentic, but it's curated. It's careful. And it's always on.

Algorithms Amplify the Performance

Layered on top of this is the algorithmic logic of the platform. Engagement drives visibility, and visibility becomes its own feedback loop. The content that performs well gets seen by more people, which reinforces the need to keep performing.

This creates pressure—not just to share, but to share in ways that are legible to the algorithm. Posts that are vulnerable, controversial, perfectly timed, or emotionally charged tend to do better. So we learn to lean into those traits. Not always consciously. But consistently.

We become participants in a system that rewards performance over presence, reaction over reflection. Attention becomes the metric of worth.

TL;DR

When social media flattens our audiences, we shift into performance mode. Self-presentation becomes a full-time job, and algorithms reinforce the behaviors that keep engagement high—even when they come at the cost of authenticity.

---

Prompt to ponder:
Who are you online—and how much of that is shaped by who you think is watching?